What the makers recommend
| Maker | Oil it names | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Lodge | Vegetable oil, melted shortening or canola; factory seasoning is soy-based vegetable oil | Not tallow, lard or ghee: can go rancid |
| Field Company | Grapeseed (factory seasoning); its own seasoning oil for home use | About 1/8 tsp on the cooking surface per round |
| Made In (carbon steel) | Grapeseed or canola | Avoid olive oil, butter, coconut and flavored oils |
Each maker's own seasoning or oils page. They publish no head-to-head test of oils, so "best" here means what makers use and the data below, not a ranking.
Best oil to season cast iron: smoke point ranges
| Oil | Smoke point range | Seasoning note |
|---|---|---|
| Canola | 400 to 450 °F | Named by Lodge and Made In |
| Grapeseed | 390 to 421 °F | Field's factory oil; Made In's top pick |
| Soybean (vegetable oil) | 450 to 495 °F | Lodge's factory oil is soy-based |
| Corn | 410 to 450 °F | Neutral; not named by these makers |
| Sunflower | 410 to 440 °F | Neutral; not named by these makers |
| Safflower | 450 to 510 °F | Neutral; not named by these makers |
| Refined avocado | 520 to 570 °F | Highest range; not named by these makers |
| Extra-virgin olive | 325 to 410 °F | Made In says avoid olive oil |
| Coconut (unrefined) | 350 to 385 °F | Made In says avoid |
| Butter | 300 to 350 °F | Made In says avoid; solids burn |
Ranges are the lowest and highest value printed by ThermoWorks and Jessica Gavin; see the smoke point chart for all 16 oils and the method. Neither source gives a lab method, so treat them as published figures, not measurements.
Why smoke point matters, and its limits
Seasoning works by heating oil past the point where it starts to smoke so it bonds to the iron. Lodge recommends a high smoke point oil and says the right oven temperature depends on the oil. But the makers' own temperatures sit above some of the published ranges: Lodge bakes at 450 to 500 °F and Made In preheats to 450 °F for grapeseed, whose range here is 390 to 421 °F. In other words, the oil is meant to be heated past its smoke point, in a thin layer, with ventilation, and published ranges differ by source. Follow your maker's temperature rather than matching a single number.
Oils to avoid for seasoning
- Beef tallow, lard and ghee: Lodge says they can go rancid when used for seasoning. They are fine for cooking if you wash, dry and oil the pan after.
- Olive oil, butter, coconut oil and flavored or infused oils: Made In says solids or sugars can burn and leave uneven patches.
- Any oil in a thick layer: Lodge and Field both say excess oil leaves a sticky surface.
How to apply the oil
Start with a clean, dry pan
Wash, dry, and warm briefly if needed.
Use a few drops
Field uses about 1/8 teaspoon on the cooking surface and a 1/4 teaspoon dab for the outside and handle.
Wipe it back
Wipe until the pan looks dry and matte. Lodge's test: nothing drips or runs when tilted.
Bake and cool
Follow your maker's temperature and time, then cool in the oven. Full steps in how to season cast iron.
Which oil should you pick?
| If you want | Pick |
|---|---|
| The same oil Lodge uses in its test kitchen | Vegetable or canola oil |
| What Field and Made In use | Grapeseed |
| Something you already have | A neutral oil from the table, thinly applied |
| To avoid rancidity risk when storing the pan | A neutral liquid oil, not animal fat |
Sources: Lodge: oils for cooking and seasoning; Field Company: seasoning instructions; Made In: seasoning carbon steel; ThermoWorks: oil smoke points; Jessica Gavin: smoke point of cooking oils. Checked November 15, 2026.









